How do you address a reviewer comment?
Do’sConsult your coauthors or a colleague who is familiar with your work. Make sure that you address each of the comments in entirely. Be polite in your response when you disagree with any comment/suggestion.Wherever required, cite references, or include supplementary/unpublished data in support of your argument.
How do you respond to reviewers?
How to reply to reviewersHave a clear structure. Start with a kind intro thanking editor and reviewers. Be precise and respond to every single comment. Challenge the reviewers, if need be. Show some ‘blood’ Exploit differences between reviewers to your benefit. Incorporate most, if not all of the additional literature the reviewers suggest.
How do you respond to peer review comments when submitting papers?
Add data, results, citations, authors, etc., without justification. Include peripheral information in your response or revised paper. Respond with yes or thank you for the comment without providing clear details of your response to the query and the changes you have made to the manuscript as a result.
What do you say in a peer review?
DoJustify your recommendation with concrete evidence and specific examples.Be specific so the authors know what they need to do to improve.Be thorough. This might be the only time you read the manuscript.Be professional and respectful. Remember to say what you liked about the manuscript!
How do you write a peer review comment?
How to Write Helpful Peer Review CommentsAvoid decision fatigue. How many decisions have you made on an average day by 11AM? List the positives and then the negatives. Give concrete examples and advice. Don’t be afraid to seek support.
What is the first step in using peer review feedback?
The first step in using peer review is deciding how to integrate relevant writing into the topics of a course. After you have selected or designed a writing assignment on a specific topic, but before you assign it, you’ll need to give your students practice in providing useful, constructive feedback.
Why is peer review important?
Peer review involves subjecting the author’s scholarly work and research to the scrutiny of other experts in the same field to check its validity and evaluate its suitability for publication. A peer review helps the publisher decide whether a work should be accepted.